Friday, December 23, 2005

Art Out of Anything: Rauschenberg in Retrospect (by Michael Kimmelman, the New York Times)




Note of the Caption: "Canyon" (1959), Robert Rauschenberg, Sonnabend Collection, New York.


"Robert Rauschenberg: Combines" will be on view at the Metropolitan Museum of Art through April 2 (2006).


slide show of the exhibition


December 23, 2005
Art Review | 'Combines'


IT is largely, if not exclusively, thanks to Robert Rauschenberg that Americans since the 1950's have come to think that art can be made out of anything, exist anywhere, last forever or just for a moment and serve almost any purpose or no purpose at all except to suggest that the stuff of life and the stuff of art are ultimately one and the same.

Stuff, in Mr. Rauschenberg's case, could mean a stuffed angora goat, like the one he picked up for $35 one day from a failing office-supply store on Eighth Avenue and girdled with an automobile tire. Originally despised, the "combines," as he called works like the shaggy "Monogram," gradually became fixed in the public imagination along with Warhol's Marilyns and Jasper Johns' flags as the classic symbols of what's American in American art.

There's no better proof of their exalted status than the current show of combines at the Metropolitan Museum, organized by Paul Schimmel of the Museum of Contemporary Art in Los Angeles and installed by Nan Rosenthal. It is big and handsome almost to a fault. There's something weird about seeing once joyfully rude and over-the-top contraptions lined up like choirboys in church, with their ties askew and shirttails out. I happened to be in the galleries when "Monogram" was solemnly uncrated: swaddled in its custom-made shroud, it was gingerly unwrapped, inspected and primped before being slid into its protective vitrine.

But even enshrined, the combines still manage to seem incredibly fresh and odd, almost otherworldly. I thought of a medieval treasury - all the rich colors and lights and intricate details.

To say that for Mr. Rauschenberg everything came together during the decade from 1954 to 1964, when he was devising these hybrids, is just to speak the literal truth. The combines mixed up paintings with bits and pieces of tattered clothes, athletic socks, newspaper clippings, grimy postcards, broken umbrellas, saw-horses, taxidermied animals, comic strips, pencil-thin neckties, light bulbs and other junk that Mr. Rauschenberg had or bought or scavenged from the street - whatever caught his fancy, which meant just about anything.

"I really feel sorry for people who think things like soap dishes or mirrors or Coke bottles are ugly, because they're surrounded by things like that all day long, and it must make them miserable," he has said, bringing to mind Whitman's remark, "I do not doubt there is far more in trivialities, insects, vulgar persons, slaves, dwarfs, weeds, rejected refuse than I have supposed."

Whitman counseled veterans in hospitals during the Civil War, and - poetic symmetry - Mr. Rauschenberg did the same for draftees and soldiers with acute combat psychoses during World War II. This, he told the art writer Calvin Tomkins years ago, was when he "learned how little difference there is between sanity and insanity and realized that a combination is essential." Which isn't a bad starting point for describing the combines.

They had many sources. When he was a little boy in the 1920's and 30's in Texas, Mr. Rauschenberg has said, his mother used to make shirts out of scraps of fabric - collage shirts. She even made herself a skirt out of the back of the suit that her younger brother, Luther, was buried in, because she didn't want the material to go to waste.

Then, as a student on instructions from Josef Albers at Black Mountain College, that crucible of the avant-garde, Mr. Rauschenberg hunted for old tin cans and stones as examples of accidental art. (Mr. Albers came to hate Mr. Rauschenberg's art so much that in later years he pretended not even to remember his former pupil.)

Cubism, Dada and Surrealism laid a general historic groundwork, Picasso, Kurt Schwitters and Joseph Cornell particular ones. And friends - John Cage, Merce Cunningham, Cy Twombly and Jasper Johns, among others - nudged Mr. Rauschenberg to transform what had been an elegant, sly, miniaturist mode of artmaking, namely collage, into something big and spectacular.

Arriving in the midst of Abstract Expressionism, the combines inevitably had the effect of a belch during a formal dinner party. But now it's plain how much they also owed to Abstract Expressionists like de Kooning. "I paint this way because I can keep putting more and more things in it - drama, anger, pain, love, a horse, my ideas about space," de Kooning said, which Mr. Rauschenberg might have said himself. Instead, he substituted the stuffed goat, a bald eagle, a pheasant and a rooster for the hypothetical horse and situated them in paintings whose virtuosity is uncannily like de Kooning's.

Mr. Rauschenberg has told an instructive story about a woman spying the offending "Monogram" in a show at the Jewish Museum during the early 60's. "To her, all my decisions seemed absolutely arbitrary - as though I could just as well have selected anything at all - and therefore there was no meaning, and that made it ugly," he recalled. "So I told her that if I were to describe the way she was dressed, it might sound very much like what she'd been saying. For instance, she had feathers on her head. And she had this enamel brooch with a picture of 'The Blue Boy' on it pinned to her breast. And around her neck she had on what she would call mink but what could also be described as the skin of a dead animal. Well, at first she was a little offended by this, I think, but then later she came back and said she was beginning to understand."

Art and life. Now, of course, it's easier to grasp the way these works weave teasing bits of autobiography with fragments of contemporary life and history to make images that can't be boiled down to a single message (academics are always trying to do this) or dismissed as a bunch of hooey (the conservative line). The sexual innuendo of the goat and tire is hard to miss. But then there are many other possible readings. Relying on the old Cubist grid for their formal armature, the combines invite decipherment without coming across, like Cubism, as homework. They provide access on many levels at once, favoring none, anticipating the mental processes of a generation of multitaskers. Half a century later, you might say, the culture has finally caught up to the combines.

The most beautiful of them tend to be the early ones: large but delicate, with a subtle, fugitive emotional pitch. They resemble elaborate quilts or shadow boxes, extrapolating from exquisite, bite-size collages that Mr. Rauschenberg had earlier devised. Sometimes, as "Levee" and "Hymnal" do, they strike a wistful, almost heartbreaking note.

Dense and self-referential, packed with insider art gags, they then become more general in their allusions, looser, airier and, by the end, formulaic. The last combines are deft but go through the motions, pointing toward the sort of big, empty, well-meaning projects that would increasingly occupy Mr. Rauschenberg as he was transformed from an impish troublemaker into the unofficial ambassador of American art.

But up to the 1960's, at least, it's like watching a ballplayer on a roll. Mr. Rauschenberg makes it all look so incredibly easy, until you look harder, and then you realize why there's nothing more difficult than making something look easy.

How, for example, in "Interview," Mr. Rauschenberg creates balance, implying weight and counterweight, by the juxtaposition of a hanging brick and a levitating softball. Or in "Small Rebus," how photographic clippings of track athletes, a bullfighter, the head of a horse and Mr. Rauschenberg's mother and sister lead the eye up, down and around in circles, in keeping with the clock face that Mr. Rauschenberg slyly paints at the picture's left edge. Or in "Dam," how he devises a cascade of letters, like a waterfall, from which leaps a skydiver, whose legs point toward the figure of a man in a photograph on a tower facing what looks like a giant turbine, which seems to stir the water.

Like paper boats, these visual connections bob and float across the surface. Deeper down, as in "Bed" (quilt, sheet and pillow, slathered with paint, framed on the wall), there is the suggestion of darker moods. A few of the combines look almost charred, blood red, with strips of fabric, akin to bandages, from which paint drips. Past the blithe comedy, the works are suffused with loss. It's there in the clocks and calendars, marking time, in the solitary figures, downtrodden, rapt in thought, long gone and far away, in the dead animals and discarded objects.

Some art tries to transcend messy reality. The combines celebrate it. They gladly barge into our world, incorporating our light and shadows, beckoning us to sit in their chairs, toss coins into their cardboard boxes, check our watches against their clocks and see our reflections in their mirrors. They're in the trenches, where real life happens.

It's beautiful down here. Just look around.

"Robert Rauschenberg: Combines" will be on view at the Metropolitan Museum of Art through April 2 (2006).

link to the original posting

The official site of the exhibition, the Metropolitan Museum of Art

Thursday, December 22, 2005

Most Expensive Art 2005 - a Connoisseur's Guide (by Leah Hoffman, Forbes)



Note of the painting: at the 4th place: (TIE) "Homage to Matisse", Mark Rothko, 1954 , Price: $22.4 million, Date Of Sale: Nov. 8, 2005, House: Christie's New York.

See the slide show of the most expensive art sold at auction in 2005 (Forbes.com)

Note from the blog editor:
For some of you who does not know me enough, I would find any excuse to put up an art work by Mark Rothko.



Both Christie's and Sotheby's should have plenty to toast this holiday season. The two auction houses--which together control some 95% of worldwide fine-art auction sales--enjoyed strong years in 2005, with record-shattering prices and robust overall sales. While the 2005 auction year saw no single sale as spectacular as 2004's $104 million Picasso (the first painting ever to crack the $100 million threshold), there were plenty of strong pieces on the market.

Christie's sold an estimated $759 million in its major fine-arts auctions in the New York market alone, up from $735 million the previous year. Though Sotheby's (nyse: BID - news - people ) no longer breaks down its annual sales by category, the results of its major auctions throughout the year suggest that the art market continued to be profitable in 2005. London's February Impressionist and modern art sales, for example, brought in $103.8 million, up 37% from last year's sale.

"It's been a stellar year across the board," said Bendetta Roux, a spokesperson for Christie's in New York.

What pieces had collectors panting? To find out, we turned to Cambridge, Mass.-based art research firm ArtFact to track down the most expensive fine art and sculpture that sold at auction in 2005.

The most expensive painting sold last year, 17th-century Venetian master Canaletto's "Venice, the Grand Canal, Looking Northeast from Palazzo Balbi to the Rialto Bridge," brought in a whopping $32.6 million. The painting--once owned by Sir Robert Walpole, Britain's first Prime Minister--was bought on July 7 by an anonymous telephone buyer at a Sotheby's auction in London. It was the highest recorded price paid at auction for a work by Canaletto, besting a record that had been set the previous day by a work sold at a Christie's New York auction. "The Bucintoro at the Molo, Venice, on Ascension Day" sold on July 6 for $20.1 million, and it remains the sixth most expensive piece sold at auction in 2005.

Indeed, many artists enjoyed record-breaking sales this year. The November sale of Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec's "La blanchisseuse (The Laundress)" for $22.4 million was a record for the artist, as was Mark Rothko's "Homage to Matisse," which sold for the same amount. Romanian-born sculptor Constantin Brancusi's "Oiseau dans l'espace (Bird in Space)," which sold for $27.5 million to an anonymous buyer in May, set sales records both for the artist's own work and for any sculpture ever sold at auction.

And what's fueling all of these sales? David Norman, director of Impressionist and modern art at Sotheby's, points to an ever-diversifying assortment of fine-art buyers. "The traditional old-money collectors are still buying, but hedge fund managers have been moving into the market in the past few years as well," he says. Newly rich buyers from Russia have begun collecting French Impressionist and modernist works, and Norman says that buyers from China and India may also soon begin speculating on Western artworks.

Word has also gotten out that well-chosen art can be a very wise investment. "Art is now a distinct asset class and a diversification strategy, even for the ordinary buyer," says Elizabeth von Habsburg, president of New York City art consultancy Masterson Gurr Johns. "That's fueling the market in a big way, and I don't think it's going to slow down anytime soon."

link to the original posting

Wednesday, December 21, 2005

Mass Media's Last Blast (By Reed Johnson, Los Angeles Times)




Note to the illustration: The mainstream mass audience is splintering into niche interests fueled by podcasting, blogging and all the rest. But do we benefit?
(Getty Images)

link to the illustration

Note from the blog editor: After few days with the blog, I learned that, some days, an editor just has more in mind than one could put on one piece a day. Not to lose some of the interesting things I saw in this couple of days, I decided to list another two articles links below my today’s choice. The additional links are related to the publishing and journalism world in New York City. I hope you would enjoy them if you have spare time to read them.


I want my MTV — and my TiVo, Palm Pilot, iPod, podcast and, of course, blog. So does America still have any interest in the big, lumbering, predictable media of Hollywood and Manhattan?



December 18, 2005

A moment of silence, please, for the imminent death of the old Mainstream Mass Culture.

Born sometime between the invention of baseball and the 1904 World's Fair, it began experiencing violent headaches and seizures shortly after Sept. 11, 2001, then lapsed into a coma during the launch of MySpace.com.

There will be no survivors, except on select reruns of "Lost." In lieu of flowers, friends may send checks to the "Bring Back Dan Rather and Tom Brokaw Emergency Fund."

There — that wasn't so painful, was it? After all, it's been common knowledge, or at least conventional wisdom, that traditional mainstream mass culture has been clinging to life for decades, like one of Anne Rice's mottled vampires. But 2005 is when a chronic condition may have turned terminal.

This was the year in which Hollywood, despite surging DVD and overseas sales, spent the summer brooding over its blockbuster shortage, and panic swept the newspaper biz as circulation at some large dailies went into free fall. Consumers, on the other hand, couldn't have been more blissed out as they sampled an explosion of information outlets and entertainment options: cutting-edge music they could download off websites into their iPods and take with them to the beach or the mall; customized newcasts delivered straight to their Palm Pilots; TiVo-edited, commercial-free programs plucked from a zillion cable channels.

The old mass culture suddenly looked pokey and quaint. By contrast, the emerging 21st century mass technoculture of podcasting, video blogging, the Google Zeitgeist list and "social networking software" that links people on the basis of shared interest in, say, Puerto Rican reggaeton bands seems democratic, consumer-driven, user-friendly, enlightened, opinionated, streamlined and sexy. Or so nearly everyone believes at the moment.

But after bidding adieu to old-fangled mass culture, the question arises: This roiling, recombinant technoculture dangles the promise of change, creativity and shared public life — but in the end, will it just come down to always-on, one-click shopping?

A decade into the Age of the Graphic Browser Interface, Americans seldom are focused on the same event or activity at the same moment. But they're congregating in enormous numbers on websites and other high-tech portals that function much like the institutions they've nudged aside. The culture's being boutiqued or, as the expression goes, "unbundled." Broadcast has given way to a proliferation of narrowcasts.

Or perhaps it's more accurate to say that Americans now have an unassuageable appetite for creating and consuming entertainment and interacting with media of all kinds, mass and otherwise. They're schlepping the kids off to "The Narnia Chronicles" and cruising the Web for old high school flames. They're loading up on Wal-Mart CDs and iTunes gift certificates. They're firing off bellicose e-mails to the Wall Street Journal and daily kos.

What's more, much of the supposedly independent and free-spirited techno-culture is being engineered (or rapidly acquired) by a handful of media and technology leviathans: News Corp., Apple, Microsoft, Yahoo and Google, the budding General Motors of the Information Age.


Linking with the like-minded

The real story isn't so much the death of the old mass culture or the rise of a new, fragmented technoculture, but the empowerment of the American consumer — which isn't quite the same as the American citizen.

Beyond racing out to get the must-hear Mariah Carey single and see Hollywood's 10-ton gorillas, We, the People are poring over iTunes playlists of friends, celebrities and strangers to find music that matches our personal preferences. And tapping services like Pandora to stream customized "radio stations" into our PCs. And browsing the endless virtual shopping aisles of opinion and analysis in the blogosphere.

En masse, people not named Rupert Murdoch or Ted Turner are using increasingly accessible technology to wrest control of cultural production — creating, curating and critiquing their own output and nudging along its consumption. An enterprising anarchist-death metal band, say, can make a video, post it on MySpace, sell its home-pressed CD off the Web and develop a base of fans who chat, post reviews and forward the video link to friends.

Maybe they sell only 10,000 CDs. But so what, says John Battelle, co-founding editor of Wired magazine. If you have 10,000 ardent fans who'll buy whatever you record, and those fans can find you directly on the Internet, you don't need a label that would grab 13 of your hard-earned bucks from every $15 CD.

Multiply one band's efforts by thousands, even millions, and you've got a culture imagining itself in an endless electronic loop of searching and citing, e-mailing and linking, getting and spending. And the engine that's driving it all is search, says Battelle, author of the recently published (and aptly titled) "The Search," a history of how Google and its rivals, in Battelle's words, "rewrote the rules of business and transformed our culture."

The shift to search-driven culture didn't happen overnight — it only looks that way in retrospect. Up through the 1990s, Battelle says, most search engines were crude, spam-choked devices that could only bring up partial texts for Web surfers to peruse.

Then Google had the novel idea of compiling databases on millions of people's search habits and began to compile what Battelle calls today's massive "Database of Intentions," a term that resonates with both Big Brother and Tomorrowland associations. Through ingenious keyword search combinations, smart engines now can direct "specific" Web traffic to sites where users have a high probability of acting "in relation to a business's goods or services" (Battelle again). In other words, to become customers or content creators of one sort or another.

This "from-the-bottom-up" transformation has touched every corner of American culture. Instead of flocking 'round the tube to watch "The Simpsons," ordinary Americans are taking advantage of ever-widening bandwidth and ever-lowering per-megabyte storage costs to star in their own five-minute, do-it-yourself programs. Check out, for instance, "The Carol and Steve Show," at stevegarfield.blogs.com, which tracks a married couple's quotidian life, complete with laconic electric bass lines between scenes, à la "Seinfeld." Or "Rocketboom," a Web-based tongue-in-cheek daily "news" cast that is produced out of its creator's Manhattan apartment and attracts 100,000 fans a day.

Advertisers, like content producers and audiences, are taking the cue, steadily drifting from television and newsprint advertising to the Web. Advertisers spent nearly $10 billion online in 2004, a figure expected to be up 30% when this year's figures are tallied. Who needs to fork over millions on the equivalent of Apple's "1984" Super Bowl ad when you can create a flash-mob with some scratchy video shot for pennies in your own backyard?

Websites like Café Press and Zazzle, engines of what some call "micro-entrepreneurialism" or "the everyone economy," allow enterprising but underfunded designers to advertise their products — mainly things like T-shirts, stickers, mugs and other items that can be easily customized with the addition of a slogan or a piece of art — but leave the actual printing, processing and shipping of the goods to the websites. Among the former site's offerings are truckers caps, beer steins and "classic thongs" engraved with the logo of … "The Carol and Steve Show."

In the existential hall of mirrors of the new mass technoculture, what goes around comes around, like plot points in a Charlie Kaufman screenplay.


Now you're the expert

BOUTIQUE culture's trickle-down effects are touching people's hearts and intellects as well as their wallets. More important than steering consumers to innovative products, services and ideas they didn't even know existed, Google, Yahoo and other intelligent search engines are linking people with other people who share their particular interests and obsessions. Ten years ago, if you had a thing for 15th century Ottoman poetry, or you were the parent of a child with a rare sleeping disorder, or you just wanted to bitch about your boss, you might have felt isolated and freakish. Now you can find or create your own audiences and support groups online, at any time of the day or night. (Not to be too gee-whiz about it — note "support groups" for neo-Nazis and the 70-plus million people visiting porn sites.)

Besides rejecting generic, bar-code-scanning consumer models in favor of specialized models, Americans are doing end runs around experts and authority figures, choosing wine on the basis of a casual blog mention instead of the pronouncement of towering critics such as Robert M. Parker Jr. Or getting their cultural criticism from text-messaging friends.

Slowly but steadily, all of American culture is becoming as customized as an East L.A. lowrider — and increasingly self-conscious of its own construction. The new mass technoculture establishes its street cred by citing and cross-referencing the works of its forebears, friends and cultural allies.

Sometimes this produces wild, revealing juxtapositions. William Shatner's iTunes celebrity playlist includes Eminem's "Lose Yourself" (clean version) along with Sir Simon Rattle and the Wiener Philharmoniker's rendition of Beethoven's Symphony No. 2 in D Major. "I've heard philosophy in music through Beethoven," quoth Capt. Kirk.

The cut-and-paste, anything-goes aesthetic of the new technoculture provides something that was sorely lacking in the old mass culture: the element of surprise, as you click through a chain of recommendations, pitches and links toward a passion for a person, product or idea you might never have started out by seeking. Alex Soojung-Kim Pang, research director of the Institute for the Future, a Silicon Valley think tank, compares the effect to opening the New Yorker and finding an article "about something that you didn't even know existed that turns out to be fascinating."

Still, the old mass culture titans aren't backing off. They're aggressively positioning themselves to regain control; if you can't beat 'em, they reason, buy 'em. "With products such as Apple's video iPod and TiVo-type digital recorders becoming widely available, Hollywood is inching toward an even more lucrative way of exploiting the home market," slate.com reports. And the new boss of that avatar of hipness, MySpace.com? Murdoch's News Corp.

The open question, though, is what the streaming, searching, boutiquing masses will bring not only to the furtherance of capital-C culture but also capital-D democracy.

Critics of the emerging technoculture point out that aesthetic taste is more than the sum of our keyword-search preferences. Tapping into another human's sensibility involves more than drawing inferences based on shared "marketing profiles."

"I'm afraid that that sort of tailoring one's universes to one's tastes creates a sort of self-imposed ghetto of tastes," says Albert Borgmann, a philosophy professor at the University of Montana who has written extensively about technology's social effects. "It can put you in touch with lots of people, but they're all your kind of people."

Its champions love to compare the Web's advent to the invention of the printing press. But what made Gutenberg's machine revolutionary was as much about what he printed — the Bible — as how he printed it. If he had published a list of his favorite songs or anguished confessions about his breakup with his girlfriend, he and his remarkable machine might not have had quite the same cultural impact.

Americans tend to embrace new technology easily — cars, television sets, the atom bomb — and postpone reckoning with the costs until decades later. Smart search engines and personal networking software are highly useful but, in and of themselves, politically and morally neutral.

"Don't be evil" is Google's admirable motto. But author Battelle and others question whether Google is always practicing what it preaches. The company recently launched a massive library book-scanning project that critics claim will violate copyright laws. Google also collects and stores tremendous amounts of users' search data and plants cookies on their computers that don't expire until 2038. Some have questioned what might happen if such data fell into the wrong hands or if government agencies under the Patriot Act compelled Google to release it.

Clickstreams are great for tracking "Desperate Housewives" backstage gossip. Preferential software is wonderful for finding tracks from a New Orleans benefit album. But will that help create a political climate in which the actual hurricane-ravaged city can be saved from abandonment and economic collapse? A click is not a vote — yet.

Some 38 years ago, Walter Cronkite, the trusted paterfamilias of "CBS Evening News," helped precipitate U.S. withdrawal from Vietnam when he used his exalted network perch to declare the Indochina War unwinnable. Cronkite is long gone from his evening post, and no anchor today commands such respect. On the other hand, today practically anyone with access to a video camera and a forwarding function can flog the nation's conscience. The new Uncle Walter may be Cindy Sheehan, the antiwar mother of a dead U.S. serviceman who gave the White House fits over its Iraq policy this year. But 15 minutes of fame do not a bully pulpit make.

Still, while network CEOs and newspaper publishers wring their hands and mutter darkly about the "balkanization" of civic consciousness, the electorate is finding new ways to stay informed. "If you type 'Sam Alito' into [blog search engine] Technorati, you get thousands of results," says Pang. "There clearly are a lot of people across the political spectrum who are blogging about this person and whether he should be on the Supreme Court…. The collective mind of the blogosphere turns out to be a reasonably good news editor."

The late social critic Christopher Lasch, author of "The Culture of Narcissism," took a darker view of whether market-based consumer empowerment can enhance citizen empowerment.

"When half the eligible voters do not even bother to vote," Lasch wrote in a prescient 1981 essay, "students of public opinion — journalists and academics alike — turn to 'culture' as the only field in which individual preferences still seem to matter. By redirecting their attention from public policy to consumer tastes, however, they unavoidably help to sustain the illusion that people can initiate sweeping changes without resorting to politics, merely by exercising their right to make individual decisions as consumers of goods, services and ideologies."

If future revolutions will not be televised, here's hoping that at least they will be podcast.


An irresistible new world

In the dozen years since the debut of Web browsers that turned the Web into a graphics-rich environment, the migration to life online has been unrelenting. Below, a small sampling of the many milestones.

1995:

* Netscape goes public. Amazon.com and eBay launch. n There are an estimated 100,000 sites on the web, up from some 623 in 1993.

1998:

* Google opens with a staff of 3.

1999:

* Blogger, one of the first popular weblog publishing tools appears.

* Craigslist, which began as an e-mail list of arts events in San Francisco, becomes an online classified ads-listing company.

2000:

* An average 52 million adults are online, about 5 million with high-speed internet access at home. As the year closes, there are 25.6 million websites.

* Google handles more than 100 million queries a day.

2001:

* Apple introduces the iPod.

2002:

* 65% of American children ages 2-17 use the Internet, up from 41% in 2000.

2003:

* MySpace and Friendster launch, putting "social networking site" in the vocabulary.

* One-millionth iPod is sold.

2004:

* Audio blogging is dubbed podcasting, and how-to articles begin to appear.

* Flickr, the photo-sharing/social networking site, launches.

* A typical day sees 128 million U.S. adults online. About 60 million have high-speed connections at home.

2005:

* eBay has 79 million U.S. members, 168 million worldwide.

* MySpace has 40 million members.

* 87% of 12- to 17-year-olds use the Internet.

* Technorati tracks 22.9 million blogs.

* By midyear, Flikr has 775,000 users and is growing about 30% a month.

* LiveJournal reports 2.5 million active accounts.

* 10 million Craigslist users search some 6.5 million classified postings each month.


Source: Pew Research Center For The People & The Press: Mid-September 2005 Political Survey, September 15 , 2005


link to the original posting


Ex-Publisher, Now Agent, Looking Both Ways (by Edward Wyatt, the New York Times)

Are Journalists underpaid? (by Daniel Gross, Slate)

Tuesday, December 20, 2005

Farewell to the Working Class (by Austin Kelley, the Nation)


[from the January 2, 2006 issue]

In 1883 Karl Marx's son-in-law, Paul Lafargue, was idling in a relatively luxurious political prison near the Latin Quarter of Paris. A Cuban-French socialist, he whiled away the days taking long lunches and discussing the evils of capitalism with his comrade and collaborator Jules Guesde, who happened to be staying in the next room. Lafargue's other prison pastimes included relaxing in the bathtub that had been delivered to his quarters (at Friedrich Engels's expense), practicing his German and, like any good nineteenth-century intellectual, revising his treatise--a pamphlet titled The Right to Be Lazy. Like most of his contemporary activists, he condemned the twelve-to-fourteen-hour factory workday, but unlike his father-in-law, he didn't just critique the conditions of labor--he went after labor itself. "In capitalist society," he wrote, "work is the cause of all intellectual degeneracy, of all organic deformity." Lafargue dismissed the "right to work" that other socialists demanded. He asked, instead, for the right to lie around on the daybed, the right to read and to nap, the right to feast and to make love. He declared the right to endless leisure.

In the past few years, Lafargue's philosophy has been vigorously renewed by writers on the other side of the Atlantic. Celebrations of leisure like Carl Honoré's In Praise of Slowness, John de Graaf's Take Back Your Time and Pat Kane's The Play Ethic have suggested that in the industrialized West we need a less hectic, more deliberate working life. In the past year two new guides to the lazy life, Tom Hodgkinson's How to Be Idle and Corinne Maier's Bonjour Laziness: Jumping Off the Corporate Ladder, have gone further, calling for a regime of revolutionary leisure in which the workforce stops being... well, a workforce. There is truly much ado about nothing here, and one must ask, Why are all these writers suddenly dedicating so much energy to indolence? Is it simply a reaction to the emerging EU and its official drive to compete with America and Asia? Or could laziness really be the key to peace, happiness and a more perfect world?

There is a substantial history of anti-work writing to draw on. Aristotle, for one, was no great fan of toil. In his Politics, he made it clear that ideal citizens should not be tradesmen, mechanics or farmers. "Such a life is ignoble, and inimical to virtue," he wrote. Instead, we must have plenty of free time and the independence to engage in social activity of our choosing. "The first principle of all action," Aristotle concluded, "is leisure." Others agreed. Cicero announced that "repose is an essential condition of happiness." Horace asked plaintively, "Why do we strive so hard in our brief lives for great possessions?"

By the time Lafargue was lounging, brandy snifter in hand, in the Sainte-Pélagie prison, the notion of striving had undergone a great shift. The elite leisure class still quoted Aristotle, thinking laziness a virtue; the Romantics and transcendentalists, meanwhile, wandered in the woods, complaining about the commerce that was tying everyone up. But the Reformation's infamous Protestant exhaustion ethic and the Industrial Revolution had altered our ideas about productivity and idleness in countless ways. Fleeing from the bustle of the busy life was a privilege of the rich, a marginal pursuit of the avant-garde or a brief, often arduous, vacation squeezed between long periods of respectable toil. For the working masses, it was forbidden fruit.

Lafargue, who was laid off by an insurance company and survived on Engels's largesse, wanted to democratize the leisure he enjoyed. He argued that the Old Testament God "gave his worshipers the supreme example of ideal laziness; after six days of work, he rests for all eternity." If each person pitched in for three hours a day, between naps and "juicy beefsteaks" and trips to the theater (in his utopian "regime of idleness," former politicians would be forced onto the stage), the world could produce everything it required--and more. Reducing the workday, he claimed, would in fact serve to increase productivity.

Lenin & Co. were not convinced, and the Soviets did not, in the end, institute sloth. But others carried the torch of radical leisure. In 1932 Englishman Bertrand Russell, feeling a bit more industrious than his French predecessor, argued for a four-hour workday. In the 1960s Raoul Vaneigem and his philosopher friends painted pro-laziness slogans ("Never Work") on Parisian walls. "The organization of work and the organization of leisure are the blades of the castrating shears whose job is to improve the race of fawning dogs," Vaneigem wrote. "One day, will we see strikers, demanding automation and a ten-hour week, choosing, instead of picketing, to make love in the factories, the offices and the culture centres?"

Spanish anarchists, Italian Marxists and American lunatics, throughout the twentieth century, called on the masses to stop working. Institutions, the thinking goes, need us to slave away at the office, at McDonald's, at the power plant. If we stop, then boom! No red tape. No burgers. No lights. Freedom! Yet despite their slogans and signs, somehow none of the pro-lazy constituency ever managed to organize millions to march into the indolent unknown.

France did institute a thirty-five-hour workweek, and other European countries offered long paid vacations (long, at least, compared with paltry American standards). But as 1960s idealism ebbed, so did the revolutionary politics of paresse. In the United States we work 20 percent more than we did in 1970; in Spain and Portugal, one can barely take an afternoon nap anymore. Even the Parisian workweek has died an ignoble death, slain by politicians' promises of increased productivity. In the battle over working hours and social services, the hours are winning and the services are losing.

In this climate, Tom Hodgkinson's How to Be Idle is a welcome cry for more time off. A young Englishman who edits a journal called The Idler, he is straightforward about his utopian aims: "I have a dream," he writes. "It is called love, anarchy, freedom. It is called being idle." Indebted to his forefathers, he quotes Paul Lafargue and Bertrand Russell at length. He even steals (as any slacker would) Lafargue's epigraph, from German philosopher Gotthold Ephraim Lessing: "Let us be lazy in everything, except in loving and drinking, except in being lazy." Such exceptions are the rule of the book. Hodgkinson insists that a commitment to leisure is essential to our spiritual and social well-being, and his enlightened state includes a strict regimen of sleeping and getting drunk.

How to Be Idle is more of an anecdotal self-help book (or anti-self-help book) than a sustained argument. "If you want health, wealth, and happiness, the first step is to throw away your alarm clocks!" Hodgkinson writes. Personal stories and friendly advice follow. He urges us to enjoy our hangovers (he assumes we are always hung over) and to drink tea and not coffee. "Coffee is for winners, go-getters, tea-ignorers, lunch-cancellers, early-risers, guilt-ridden strivers, money obsessives and status-driven spiritually empty lunatics." At one point he even tells us where to buy our furniture (thrift stores, auctions and, of course, eBay).

The book is stitched together loosely, with each chapter corresponding to an hour of the day ("3 p.m.: The Nap" and "2 a.m.: The Art of Conversation") and liberally sprinkled with the wisdom of a diverse crew of loafers, from Wilde and Nietzsche to Debbie Harry and Spinal Tap. He, like Lafargue, blames the captains of industry for sanctifying labor: "The great problem of the Industrial Revolution," he writes, "was how to transform a population of strong-willed, independent-minded, heavy-drinking, party-oriented, riot-loving, life-loving Englishmen into a docile, disciplined, grateful workforce."

Hodgkinson is most entertaining--and convincing--when he's on a tirade. He rails against Thomas Edison ("After Edison, the machines never rested"), celebrates long aimless walks ("The pedestrian is the highest and most mighty of beings....he wanders detached, wise and merry, godlike. He is free") and discourages readers from dousing symptoms with pharmaceuticals in order to carry on, still sick, with work. "Drug companies," he writes, "make vast profits out of magic beans which promise to deliver us from torment and return us to the desk." Hodgkinson would like instead to bring back the word "convalescence." He suggests that physicians should prescribe long periods of rest--anywhere from three days to two months--for minor illnesses. "Doctors, join us!" he writes. "I call on you! You are servants of the work ethic!"

He is on familiar terms with the figures of high culture he quotes. German critic Walter Benjamin is "one of the great literary Euro-slackers of the early twentieth century"; René Descartes, he tells us, was an incorrigible late-sleeper. When studying with the Jesuits, his tutors would douse him with buckets of cold water--to no effect. Hodgkinson wisely attributes Descartes's philosophical inventiveness to his time lying prone. "Laziness produced Cartesian duality," he writes. Then he adds, "I lie in bed thinking, therefore I am."

Corinne Maier's slim manifesto is a cross between Jacques Lacan and Dilbert, an abstract French psychoanalytic office cartoon. Her book is aimed at corporate life and the modern middle manager, whom she advises to slack off while keeping one foot on the office desk. "It's in your best interest," she writes, "to work as little as possible." (Maier herself works only a few hours a week.) This "active disengagement," she continues, will "undermine the system from within." Although Bonjour Laziness is peculiarly French (Maier's attacks on business language, which are largely assaults on imported Americanisms, may be lost in translation), many of the book's criticisms (CEO excesses, financial scandals) will be familiar to American cubicle dwellers and newspaper readers. If workers believe in their companies, she thinks, they are deluded. If they believe their jobs are secure, they are fools. And if they trust they can get ahead by working hard, they are certifiably insane.

Maier's response is to drop out. She tells the office worker to pretend to be working but not to commit to anything. "Seek out the most useless positions: those in consultancy, appraisal, research, and study," she commands. The rise of freelancing and outsourcing has created a workforce to which companies are less responsible, so you should be less responsible to them. (About temporary workers, she writes, "treat them well: remember, they're the only ones who actually do any work.")

From bourgeois ennui to Starbucks jokes ("How does the world end? Not with a bang but with a Starbucks"), this is mostly well-worn territory. Like Hodgkinson, Maier is erudite but muddled, her book full of subheadings but no structure. Also like Hodgkinson, she relies on rhetorical excess to bring her ideas to life. About the managerial emphasis on flexibility, she writes, "To be always available for a long list of unlikely projects--half of which are completely idiotic, the other half ill-conceived--is a little like changing sexual partners twice a year. When you're twenty, the idea might have a certain charm; but over the years, frankly, it becomes a chore. The New Management is an erection on command."

Of course, one might object to all this lazy business. What if you have to work to feed your family, to stave off poverty or sickness, to afford necessities? What if (gasp!) you really like your job? In other words, who do these writers think they are talking to? Both Maier and Hodgkinson treat the reader as a friend, someone to tease and to instruct, someone who will understand them implicitly. This is a fun game, and I'd love to join them for a series of long lunches. (Considering Maier's sales figures, buoyed by a well-publicized battle with her employer, there might be a lot of people at the table.) On the other hand, maybe all we want to do, as readers, is to fantasize about a long lunch while chowing down a Power Bar and hurrying off to the gym. These books offer a bit of vicarious indiscretion to the worker bee or, more precisely, to the educated, upper-middle-class Barnes & Noble shopper. When they ask us to change our lives radically, they do so with offhand irony tucked under cheery cartoonish covers.

In this way, the authors distinguish themselves from the layabouts of the past. Our modern loungers have chosen book deals over communal action, even of the artistic kind. Hodgkinson, for one, divides the world into idlers and "botherers," those letter-writing, protest-marching busybodies who are always mucking things up. He is so hard-pressed to imagine desires other than his own pleasures that we don't find out he has a family until we are nearly done with the book. (Children, it seems, like prime ministers, are botherers.)

Maier is equally dismissive of social action, despite her Marxian rhetoric ("Nowadays each of us is an object of exchange, destined to be placed and displaced at the whim of the firm"). Arguing for political apathy, she writes, "Humanity never ceases repeating the same mistakes, with its red tape, its extremely mediocre leaders, and...its gallows." Toward the end of Bonjour Laziness, she presents us with an ideological choice: a belief in nationalized industries, strong unions and social welfare programs, or free markets and versatile globalism. The first is a dinosaur, based on "simpleminded egalitarianism" and a nostalgic, antiglobal ideal; the second masks cruelty in the guise of progress and democracy. Maier's response: "By refusing to subscribe to either one, you can at least have the satisfaction of feeling intelligent." With all that time on her hands, she might have come up with something more appealing, or at least wittier. If Aristotle once thought leisure was necessary for political action, Maier seems to think it's only an expression of smug self-satisfaction.

This current crop of European idlers may not provide a template for a better, more leisurely democracy. Nor will they convince you to quit your job to pursue poetry or to dedicate yourself to the People's Coalition for the Ten-Hour Week. Still, they offer a dollop of rebellious pleasure and their own brands of earnest utopian thinking. And who knows? Maybe you'll put down their books, log on to eBay and buy yourself a daybed. If, as Hodgkinson writes, "the art of living is the art of bringing dreams and reality together," that's not such a bad start.

link to the original posting

Sunday, December 18, 2005

Human Face Is Library's Heart (by Nicole Brodeur, the Seattle Times)



Caption Note: Richmond Beach branch of the King County Library System
caption source
Note from the blog editr: Richmond Beach is located in the city of Shoreline bordered the North of Seattle.



Illustration note: Nicole Brodeur (Seattle Times)


Sunday, December 18, 2005

It was our Thursday night ritual back in Carolina. The K&W cafeteria for dinner and an evening among the stacks at the Cameron Village Library.

Over the weeks and years, the librarians there became family; surrogate aunts who introduced my son to Mike Mulligan, showed him Where the Wild Things Are, and sat beside him while the Titanic sank. So I understand the quiet riot that started at the Richmond Beach branch of the King County Library last month when it was announced that longtime librarian Anina Sill would be transferred to work at the Bothell, Kenmore and Lake Forest Park branches.

Sill's move is part of the library's system of clustering — spreading staffers among two or three branches to share their time and gifts. Since 2001, about half of KCLS's branches have been clustered.

But in Richmond Beach, Sill's deployment to three out-of-town branches felt like Mister Rogers had been booted from his neighborhood.

She lives next door to the branch and has been working there for 32 years — since she was 16. She even has a column in the Richmond Beach Community News.

Her December piece was bittersweet: "As your Richmond Beach librarian, I bid you a fond adieu; as your neighbor, I'll see you around."

Patrons petitioned KCLS Director Bill Ptacek, who said Sill may return to the Richmond Beach-Shoreline cluster next spring.

But neighbors still fret over the cost of clustering.

"You read about people wanting third places, and that's what this one is for us," said Ann Shulz, 55, who moved to Richmond Beach in 1981 because "walking to the library was my idea of heaven."

Her children found the library a welcoming place, even taking their hamsters in for a visit with librarians.

Again, I understand the value of a home away from home, where people know one another yet can travel to faraway places, one page at a time.

The clustering is a response to the system's success, Ptacek said. Book circulation is up 6 percent from last year, when the KCLS was named the second-busiest library system in the country.

Also last year, voters passed a bond issue that will allow the library system to build three new libraries and expand several others. But since the system depends on property taxes, operational costs are limited.

"We're taking the exact same staff resources and using them in a more flexible way," he said. "It's not like we're taking librarians away from the community they're serving. They'll just be down the road."

Shulz is skeptical: "All we know is what we care about, which is we have a small library and we like it that way."

I get that. Start pulling at the few connections that we still have in our communities and they are bound to fall apart. I understand the need to manage costs, but there are places where people matter more than just money.

One book can open a mind. And sometimes it takes a trusted, familiar hand to find it.

Trust me.

Nicole Brodeur's column appears Sunday, Tuesday and Thursday. Reach her at 206-464-2334 or nbrodeur@seattletimes.com.

She still misses Cathy and Grace.


Copyright © 2005 The Seattle Times Company

link to the original posting

link to the King County Library System

Seeing Out Loud - Having an eye in criticism is as important as having an ear in music (by Jerry Saltz, the Village Voice)


Illustration Note: This Cartoon doesn’t come with the article, but from the same publication. Bush and Cheney Answer Critics, 'Majority of Americans are un-American' by Ward Sutton, November 18th, 2005 5:21 PM
Link to the Original Illustration Posting



December 16th, 2005 6:29 PM


This month is my seven-year anniversary at the Voice, so I thought I'd use Frieze magazine's recent queries to me about the "de-skilling of art criticism" and "our post-critical era" as a way to write about what I think I'm trying to do here. First, I fretted I was the kind of "de-skilled" critic Frieze was referring to. I have no degrees. I started out as an artist, stopped painting, and became a long-distance truck driver. My CB handle was "the Jewish Cowboy": Shalom, partner. I didn't begin writing criticism until I was almost 40. All I knew was I loved art and had to be in the art world. The truth is, I wasn't sure what Frieze meant by "de-skilled." It sounded vaguely bad. But to me de-skilled means unlearning other people's ideas of skill. All great contemporary artists, schooled or not, are essentially self-taught and are de-skilling like crazy. I don't look for skill in art; I look for originality, surprise, obsession, energy, experimentation, something visionary, and a willingness to embarrass oneself in public. Skill has nothing to do with technical proficiency; it has to do with being flexible and creative. I'm interested in people who rethink skill, who redefine or reimagine it: an engineer, say, who builds rockets from rocks.
The best critics look for the same things in contemporary criticism that they look for in contemporary art. But they also have an eye. Having an eye in criticism is as important as having an ear in music. It means discerning the original from the derivative, the inspired from the smart, the remarkable from the common, and not looking at art in narrow, academic, or "objective" ways. It means engaging uncertainty and contingency, suspending disbelief, and trying to create a place for doubt, unpredictability, curiosity, and openness.

Dishearteningly, many critics have ideas but no eye. They rarely work outside their comfort zone, are always trying to reign art in, turn it into a seminar or a clique, or write cerebral, unreadable texts on mediocre work. There's nothing wrong with writing about weak art as long as you acknowledge the work's shortcomings. Seeing as much art as you can is how you learn to see. Listening very carefully to how you see, gauging the levels of perception, perplexity, conjecture, emotional and intellectual response, and psychic effect, is how you learn to see better.

Art is a way of thinking, a way of knowing yourself. Opinions are tools for listening in on your thinking and expanding consciousness. Many writers treat the juiciest part of criticism, judgment, as if it were tainted or beneath them. The most interesting critics make their opinions known. Yet in most reviews there's no way to know what the writer thinks, or you have to scour the second-to-last paragraph for one negative adjective to detect a hint of disinclination. This is no-risk non-criticism. Being "post-critical" isn't possible. Everyone is judging all the time. Critics who tell you they're not judging or that they're being objective are either lying or delusional. Being critical of art is a way of showing it respect. Being subjective is being human.

Yet people regularly say, "You shouldn't write on things you don't like." This breaks my heart. No one says this to theater critics, film reviewers, restaurant critics, or sports writers. No one says, "Just say all the food was good." Nowadays, many see criticism mainly as a sales tool or a rah-rah device. Too many critics enthuse over everything they see or merely write descriptively. This sells everyone short and is creating a real disconnect. People report not liking 80 percent of the shows they see, yet 80 percent of reviews are positive or just descriptive.

Obviously, critics can't just hysterically love or hate things, or assert that certain types of art or media are inherently bad (e.g., no one has actually believed that painting is dead since the Nixon administration, yet writers regularly beat this dead horse). Critics must connect their opinions to a larger set of circumstances; present cogent arguments; show how work does or doesn't seem relevant, is or isn't derivative; explain why an artist is or isn't growing. As with Melville's ideas about art, criticism should have: "Humility—yet pride and scorn/Instinct and study; love and hate/Audacity and reverence." Good criticism should be vulnerable, chancy, candid, and nervy. It should give permission, have attitude, maybe a touch of rebellion, never be sanctimonious or dull, and be written in a distinctive, readable way. Good critics should be willing to go on intuition and be unafraid to write from parts of themselves they don't really know they have.

If criticism is in trouble, as many say, it's because too many critics write in a dreary hip metaphysical jargon that no one understands except other dreary hip metaphysicians who speak this dead language. They praise everything they see, or only describe. These critics are like the pet owner who sews up the cat to stop it from fouling the sofa: They keep the couch clean but kill the cat.

Mystic Cryptic Revelations

Young painters should look at the work of Charles Burchfield (1893–1967), the mystic, cryptic painter of transcendental landscapes, trees with telekinetic halos, and haunted houses emanating ectoplasmic auras. Burchfield, who like Hopper painted as if cubism never happened, is van Gogh by way of Caspar David Friedrich, Marsden Hartley, John Marin, calendar art, and Sunday painting. Consciously or not, recent painters like Peter Doig, Verne Dawson, Gregory Amenoff, and Ellen Altfest are channeling bits of Burchfield's visionary vibe.

One reason more young artists aren't familiar with this great American may have to do with Burchfield being yet another painter who is left out of the Museum of Modern Art's narrow-minded, mad march through modernism. Although he had three retrospectives at the Whitney, one at MOMA (way back in 1930), and one at the Met, Burchfield continues to be an odd man out of modern-art history.

In this patchy but occasionally stirring survey of 33 works on paper, you can track Burchfield in landscapes that have a Blakean spookiness. Like Hartley, Burchfield brings a mad I-see-everything- at-once spirituality to his work. Landscape With Rain, from 1917, looks both like a God's-eye view of a valley and God's half-closed eye. The 1917 Sun Setting in a Bank of Smoke is a modern-day Star of Bethlehem scene with five glowing extraterrestrial orbs hovering near an old house and another blazing above. Several late works, notably the electric-orange Butterfly Tree, from 1960, and a drawing from 1964–65 of a metaphysical tree that looks like an alien hairdo and a coxcomb, suggest that Burchfield wasn't only good early on but was one of the better American painters of the early '60s, as well.

Dangerous Minds: An Art Dealer in Motion

For the last 15 years gallerist Andrea Rosen has offered a studious, restive, exuberant outlook about art. But also philosophic. Ask her something and she'll give you a "history of" answer. Lately, she seems to be expanding her vision to good effect. "Looking at Words," which features more than 300 works on paper hung salon-style, is her latest foray into exhibition-as-investigation. All the works have words in them, although, interestingly, you look through the letters and the words at the images themselves. Physicality trumps reading. Confronting this much material in one room is daunting. But it's worth it, if only to glean the mind of an art dealer in motion.


link to the original posting

Friday, December 16, 2005

What Are the Blogs Saying About Me? (By PAMELA PAUL, the New York Times)




Illustration by M. K. Perker (the New York Times)


Thanks to blog search engines like Technorati, IceRocket and Feedster, writers have easy access to the latest entries, where bloggers and their readers post both in-depth and off-the-cuff reactions to the books they're reading. Some readers expound on books on their pages on MySpace, a social networking site popular among younger people. From near-professional literary sites like Beatrice and MaudNewton to rough online diaries, blogs offer insight into what readers are thinking in a way that Amazon, with its simplistic star spectrum and short (and often manipulated) reviews, does not.
[View a selection of the most blogged-about books of 2005.]

For some authors, blogs provide the first indication that someone other than family members and people who owe them favors are reading their books. "Blogs are like reports from a far-flung world," said Joshua Wolf Shenk, author of "Lincoln's Melancholy: How Depression Challenged a President and Fueled His Greatness." "It's the first evidence that there's a conversation out there about my book I wasn't aware of," he said. "My instinct is enormous curiosity about who these people are."

That interest, oddly, isn't always reciprocated. A. J. Jacobs, author of "The Know-It-All: One Man's Humble Quest to Become the Smartest Person in the World," was miffed to find a blogger who described his own efforts to read the Encyclopaedia Britannica from A to Z, just as Jacobs did for his book. But after seeing that the blogger credited him, Jacobs e-mailed him compliments and an offer of support. The blogger never wrote back. "I guess he's too busy reading the encyclopedia," Jacobs said.

Of course, the blogosphere can also be a rough place for fragile egos. Rick Moody, a self-described "suppurating wound of vulnerability," admits to having plugged his name into Technorati on several occasions. "I can graph it onto my serotonin levels," said Moody, whose new novel is "The Diviners." "It's like taking a pill to enhance suicidal ideation. Even the good ones make me want to kill myself."

Years ago, after someone sent Amy Tan a link to a Web site where one anti-fan declared "Amy Tan must die," Tan fired off a prophylactic e-mail message asking friends and colleagues not to forward comments culled from the Internet. "I think it's great that readers are having spontaneous dialogues about my work online," she said, "but I don't think I should necessarily listen in." She likens looking herself up online to overhearing gossip at a cocktail party. "You might hear some good things about yourself, but you may also hear something devastating."

Also among the blogophobic is Maureen Dowd. "I'm super sensitive and I think I'd get too depressed," said Dowd, whose new book is "Are Men Necessary?: When Sexes Collide." Instead, she employs proxy searchers. "It seems narcissistic to be trolling around looking for mentions of yourself, though I am thrilled to be blogged about," she said. "My sister and my assistant show me things they think I need to see. But I don't want to get too caught up in it myself."

While the temptation to correct errors - which often reverberate from blog to blog - can be strong, counterblogging can be counterproductive. Authors report sad tales of the flaming feedback loops that follow such confrontations. David Marcus, author of "What it Takes to Pull Me Through: Why Teenagers Get in Trouble and How Four of Them Got Out," discovered a blog insinuating he had been paid off by one of the schools he profiled. "My gut was to dash out a denial, but then I checked myself," he recalled. "I realized that all a response would do is spread this untruth from one electronic forum to another and give substance to the accusation."

Occasionally, however, authors' interactions with their bloggers prove fruitful. Cass Sunstein read a discussion of one of his articles about conservative judicial radicalism on The Volokh Conspiracy, a group blog organized by Eugene Volokh, a law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles, in which Sunstein was invited to respond. "We had an interesting exchange and there were a lot of comments," said Sunstein, who teaches law at the University of Chicago. The discussion even spurred him to make changes to "Radicals in Robes," the book he was writing at the time. "There's no question that 'Radicals in Robes' was affected by a kind of pre-publication review on a blog," he said.

But unlike formal reviewers, bloggers aren't inhibited by the fact-checker's pencil or concern for professional reputation. Stephen J. Dubner, co-author of "Freakonomics" and an avid blog reader, happened upon the blog of someone who had given "Freakonomics" a middling review in a major newspaper. On his blog, however, the reviewer let loose, saying in less than delicate language that he thought the book really stank.

At best, blogs can be the electronic version of word-of-mouth selling. Luis Alberto Urrea has written more than 10 books, but it wasn't until he published his novel "The Hummingbird's Daughter" earlier this year that he experienced the joys of being blogged (sympathetically) on sites like Bookslut and La Bloga. "I had never paid attention to that whole world before," said Urrea. Now, he has his wife comb the Web every morning, filtering out anything too harsh. "You're always braced for bad news," he said, "but blogs have been so friendly." Urrea (who said he responded to every e-mail message he got) compares the blog world to a country store with a cracker barrel, where he and his readers are playing checkers. "It's so immediate and informal."

Diana Abu-Jaber, whose recent memoir "The Language of Baklava" became a staple on food blogs this year, takes a similarly rosy view. "It's wonderful when people send me e-mails and letters, but when you read a blog, about your book, you feel like you're entering into a conversation," she said. "People develop ideas and apply your book to their lives in a very immediate way." After uncovering a community of cooking blogs where readers exchange recipes and stories, Abu-Jaber responded to a number of bloggers, eager to share recipes. "They seemed shocked when I wrote," she said. "I have the feeling they weren't sure people actually were reading them."

But at least one author who has spent time on both sides of a blog takes a more mixed view. "Blogs can hurt because they're so personal," said Julie Powell, who turned her popular blog about cooking her way through Julia Child's "Mastering the Art of French Cooking" into the book "Julie and Julia." "Nobody's getting paid, there's a lot of invective." Powell's own experience as a blogger has inured her to some of the more vicious comments, including the torrent of abuse directed at her after she said something "very ill-considered" about food bloggers in an interview with Salon (which was also host to her blog). "An author who writes his book in solitude is protected from reader responses along the way. Whereas as a blogger, you're used to hearing those responses, good and bad."

Having gone from blog to book, Powell says she's turned into a bad citizen of the blogosphere, no longer regularly checking herself out on blogs. "To me," she said, "seeing myself in print media is the fascinating thing."

Pamela Paul is the author, most recently, of "Pornified: How Pornography Is Transforming Our Lives, Our Relationships and Our Families."



link to the original posting

A Cradle of Civilization Rocked by War (By Thomas H. Maugh II, Times Staff Writer, the New York Times)


Caption Note: RUINS: Excavations at Tell Hamoukar, in Syria, have uncovered the remains of a settlement devastated in a large-scale war in 3500 BC, possibly by Uruk, a Mesopotamian city-state 400 miles away.(Univrsity of Chicago)(Times)


December 16, 2005

Excavations at a ruined city on the plains of northeastern Syria have turned up the oldest known example of large-scale warfare — a massive campaign that pummeled the city into submission at the dawn of civilization more than 5,500 years ago, researchers said Thursday.

The discovery of the devastated remains of the ancient trading center suggests that the urge to attack and conquer cities is as old and basic as the need to build them, the researchers said.

"This clearly was no minor skirmish," said archeologist Clemens Reichel of the University of Chicago's Oriental Institute, who led the joint U.S.-Syrian team that made the discovery. "This was 'shock and awe' in the 4th millennium BC."

The siege and destruction of the site, now known as Tell Hamoukar, was apparently an early step by Uruk, an ancient Mesopotamian city-state, to establish the world's earliest colonial system, said archeologist Guillermo Algaze of UC San Diego, who was not involved in the research.

"What makes it fascinating is it's so modern," Algaze said. "Change the names and change the time period, and we could be discussing European colonization of the New World 500 years ago."

Experts compared the finding to the discovery of the fabled city Troy, which was thought to be mythological until its site was found in Turkey nearly 3,000 years after its fall.

The people of Uruk were establishing colonies 400 to 600 miles away from their own city, Algaze added. "We never quite realized they could do that in 3500 BC."

The Tell Hamoukar site was discovered in 1999 by a joint U.S.-Syrian team led by archeologist McGuire Gibson of the Oriental Institute. Before the discovery, researchers had believed that civilization began 400 miles southeast at Ur and Uruk, Sumerian cities in the so-called Fertile Crescent between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers in what is now southern Iraq, and spread northward.

Tell Hamoukar was at least as old as the better-known cities of Mesopotamia. Its discovery indicated that civilizations were already thriving this early in history and that the idea of cities had evolved independently among several groups of people.

Those people had first settled in the area much earlier, about 9,000 BC. That was about 2,500 years before the first settlements in China and 6,000 years before the first ones in Western Europe.

The people of Uruk dominated the region for at least 2,000 years, eventually giving way to the Babylonians and the Assyrians.

Located about five miles from the Iraqi border, Tell Hamoukar had all the traits now associated with cities, including city walls, communal food production, breweries and bureaucracy.

The settlement was unusual, however, for having no recognizable waterway nearby. Virtually all other cities from early periods were located on the banks of rivers. Gibson's team speculated that the city was founded to service a crucial trade route from the ancient city of Nineveh, 60 miles to the northeast, to the Mediterranean Sea, and that it became prosperous doing so.

Gibson's team found some evidence of burning and destruction in the ancient city, but the causes were not clear and they had to abandon their excavations for three years because of the war in Iraq and deteriorating relations between Syria and the United States.

When Reichel led a team back there this summer, the cause of the burning became clear. "The whole area of our most recent excavation was a war zone," he said.

The team found heavily damaged walls and buildings, extensive burning and many implements of warfare — especially clay "bullets" and balls used by the invaders.

The team found more than 1,200 intact bullets, each about 1 1/2 inches long and 1 inch in diameter, and about 120 larger balls about 2 1/2 to 4 inches in diameter, along with much larger numbers of shattered balls.

Their purpose was initially a mystery, but researchers soon noticed that many of them had been flattened on one side by impact with a solid object. The flattened sides bore characteristic impressions from the plastered walls of the buildings, suggesting that they were still damp when used.

Both varieties would have been propelled by slings, with the smaller bullets directed against people and the larger ones aimed at walls and buildings.

"They could undoubtedly inflict major harm," Reichel said.

The team also uncovered three major buildings inside the walls, each with the "tripartite" layout characteristic of the period, with a large central courtyard surrounded by smaller work and storage rooms. The chambers yielded hundreds of inscribed clay tablets used to seal doors, bottles and a variety of other containers.

Pottery and other artifacts in the buildings were from the local culture, dating from the late Stone Age. "These were not southern Mesopotamians, but local people," Reichel said.

The picture of the battle is still largely incomplete and will probably remain so, Reichel said. "We don't know how many people were involved or how it took place. But it was probably a short battle because everything was left in place."

That's good for archeologists, he said, because finding artifacts in place will help them understand the patterns and routines of daily life.

The team is also not sure who attacked the city. But excavation of the soil directly above the ruins revealed caches of pottery shards and other artifacts from Uruk.

"If the Uruk people weren't the ones firing the sling bullets, they certainly took advantage of it," he said. "They took over this place right after its destruction."

Unfortunately, he added, most of the evidence of that occupation has been erased by erosion over the millenniums.


link to the original posting

Thursday, December 15, 2005

Who Needs Facts? Flashy Headlines are Much More Fun (by Liz Cox Barrett, Columbia Journalism Review Daily)


Illustration Note: The World According to Bill O'Reilly
by Tom Tomorrow, December 13th, 2005 11:00 AM. [Media has it. The illustration did not come with the article, but still related to media. from the Village Voice.]
link to the illustration source

Dec. 08, 2005 - 7:01 PM
The Sky is Falling!
Who Needs Facts? Flashy Headlines are Much More Fun
(by Liz Cox Barrett, Columbia Journalism Review Daily)


"House party is over," declared CNN in a headline on its Web site this morning, pointing to the UCLA Anderson Forecast, a widely-watched report on the U.S. economy that includes predictions for the housing market.

If the party is over, then the Los Angeles Times must be the annoying guest who refuses to leave, refreshing his drink one more time as the hostess stifles a yawn. The newspaper had a different take on the same report: "Hot Housing Market Still 'Cruising,'" screamed its headline.

Well, some newly minted MBA might point out that UCLA Anderson released multiple forecasts yesterday, including one for the nation and one specific to California. Perhaps that explains why CNN is calling it a night while they're partying on in LA.

But there are mixed messages from the press even within California. While the Los Angeles Times was "Still 'Cruising'," up north the Contra Costa Times was carrying the headline, "Housing Market to Slow, Not Crash." And, back in LA, there was a major buzz kill in the unlikeliest of places: college. "Anderson Forecast Predicts Looming Crash," proclaimed the UCLA Bruin. Then again, the Bruin piece also contradicts itself. The subhed reports that "leading economists say real estate bubble may burst, lead to recession" while in the body of the article the only "leading economist" to address this issue actually says that "a recession caused by a burst in the housing market is unlikely." When the Bruin staffers graduate, they will no doubt have an easy transition to writing nonsensical copy for California's major papers.

So, which is it? Crash? No Crash? Is the party over, or is it merely evolving from a lavish affair with an open bar to something more like a casual get-together around a keg?

Let's go to the primary source, shall we? The Audit, presumably like all the reporters whose work we cite, got its hands on hard copies of all of yesterday's UCLA Anderson reports, which apparently are not available online. UCLA Anderson Forecast Senior Economist Michael Bazdarich gives his report on the national housing market the following headline: "Housing May Be Beginning a Decline." Not exactly "Party is over," is it? And Bazdarich may as well have been writing directly to CNN (or the Bruin, or any number of media outlets who have recently reported that the housing bubble is now bursting) when he notes in his opening paragraph that "we strongly believe [a housing decline] is going to occur ... nevertheless such turns do not always take shape as soon as one might think they should, and so a little patience in calling and waiting for them is usually a wise take."

Meanwhile, Economist Ryan Ratcliff writes in his California-specific report that "our forecast essentially mirrors the national forecast." So, no, UCLA Anderson's outlook for California is not sunnier than its outlook for the nation.

Returning to the national forecast, in the second paragraph Bazdarich writes, "... there are some signs of late that housing activity is starting to head lower" although "the indications are mainly anecdotal and so it is still too early to call the turn."

Not "too early" for some reporters, apparently -- although it looks like CNN has re-thought its headline since we first began writing this post (the current headline focuses on predicted job losses in the financial sector, another aspect of yesterday's Anderson report). Still, can we really blame the person at CNN who came up with the original "party's over" headline? After all, he's competing for eyeballs with click-worthy CNN headlines such as "Ann Coulter to Audience: You're Stupider Than I Am" and "White House: Bush Daughter Not Engaged."

link to the original posting

Wednesday, December 14, 2005

Till Derrida do us part (a vow by Cary Wolfe and Allison Hunter, posted on Harper's)



Posted on Thursday, August 25, 2005. The following transcript is from the June 1 wedding of Cary Wolfe and Allison Hunter. Wolfe teaches critical theory at SUNY Albany; Hunter is an artist. Originally from August 2002.
JUDGE SILVERMAN: Friends and relatives, we are gathered here today to witness the marriage of Allison and Cary. To do so, we must perform these vows in an act of ceremony.


But what are these things: to wed, to marry, to take a wedding vow? They are what the philosopher J. L. Austin, in his study How to Do Things With Words, calls “speech acts,” of which there are two different kinds: constative speech acts, whose primary attribute is that they say something; and performative speech acts (of which this ceremony is an example), whose primary attribute is that they do something. A performative speech act, as Austin puts it, doesn't describe a state of affairs; it possesses the crucial feature of accomplishing the very act to which it refers. The very act of saying it makes it so.

It's not enough just to think the words of the wedding vow, no matter how sincerely you may be thinking them. (If it were enough, then I wouldn't be here and neither would you.) And it's not enough even to say them. (If it were, Allison and Cary could just recite these lines to each other on the subway, say, or while making risotto, and—voila—they'd be married.)

Although we've just begun the ceremony—or have we?—some interesting questions have already gathered on the horizon: Is this set of words, so far, “accepted”? Are they “appropriate for the invocation of the particular procedure invoked”? Are we executing the procedure “correctly” and “completely”? Is it enough simply to say, “Do you, Allison, take Cary to be your lawfully wedded husband?”

ALLISON: “I do.”

JUDGE SILVERMAN: “And do you, Cary, take Allison to be your lawfully wedded wife?”

CARY: “I do.”

JUDGE SILVERMAN: As it turns out, it is enough, and the words just uttered by both Allison and Cary are sufficient—but not because of the words themselves.

First of all—according to Austin and according to the law—the words must be meant “seriously” and not self-referentially.

The problem with that, though, as Jonathan Culler has pointed out in his discussion of Jacques Derrida's critique of Austin, is that the distinction between serious and nonserious is always uncertain, always subject to deconstruction, and any attempt to solve that problem by insisting on the “proper” context for a statement is bound to fail.

For example, we are all familiar with the signs at airport security checkpoints that read, “All remarks concerning bombs and weapons will be taken seriously.” Such signs, Culler notes, attempt “to preclude the possibility of saying in jest, `I have a bomb in my shoe,' by identifying such utterances as serious statements. But this codification fails to arrest the play of meaning,” because “the structure of language grafts this codification onto the context it attempts to master,” creating “new opportunities for obnoxious behavior,” such as, “If I were to remark that I had a bomb in my shoe, you would have to take it seriously, wouldn't you?”—a statement “whose force is a function of context but which escapes the prior attempt to codify contextual force.”

It's a bit like George Carlin's observation about those same signs. “NO JOKES,” perhaps, “but what about riddles?”

Our point is that the distinction between “serious” and “nonserious” as determining what makes a performative binding doesn't solve the problem; it only pushes it back a notch. At which point, we can only fall back on the very invocation of “sincerity” that Austin's idea of the performative seems designed to deflate. We can only ask, Did you, Cary and Allison, seriously mean what you just said about taking each other as husband and wife?

CARY AND ALLISON: Yes, we did.

JUDGE SILVERMAN: Okay, good. Now we're getting somewhere, legally speaking. Austin may in the end be wrong, as Derrida suggests, about seriousness being decisive, but what he is right about is this: when such words are uttered in the “appropriate” context—by two parties who have obtained a marriage license, presided over by me (“by the power vested in me,” as one often hears), and so on—then those words are nevertheless binding, no matter what anyone thinks.

All of which is why the very first definition of the word “marry” in the Oxford English Dictionary is “to join for life as husband and wife according to the laws and customs of a nation”. And this, in turn, is why it is misguided to think that what validates a wedding ceremony is the making public of innermost feelings, and the sincerity or earnestness thereof. That may be a satisfactory performance, but it is beside the point of the wedding vow as a performative.

This is why Austin insists (in a stipulation almost too good to be true for our purposes) that “the act of marrying, like, say, the act of betting”—which is, incidentally, one of the meanings of the word “wed”—“is to be described as saying certain words, rather than as performing a different, inward and spiritual, action of which these words are merely the outward and audible sign.”

To understand the act otherwise—to see it as, indeed, the outward sign of an inward and spiritual action—is precisely what makes most wedding vows written by the bride and groom so unsatisfactory to Cary and Allison.

Such pronouncements, heartfelt though they may be, indulge in a fundamental misunderstanding. They do not understand that the power of the wedding vow as a performative utterance derives not from its external registration of the bride and groom's intimate, spiritual feelings—as if somehow the more heartfelt and confessional your ceremony is, the more married you are—but rather from the external, conventional nature of the act itself.

This is why Cary and Allison are not going to drone on today about how much they care about each other, how they promise to do this and not do that, and so on. First of all, they assume that you all already know how they feel about each other without being told in graphic and maudlin detail—that's why you're here. And second of all, it takes a lifetime, not twenty minutes, for two people to define for themselves what the word “marriage” means. Your presence here is simply to witness their commitment to undertake such a definition.

In sum, then, it is not the “uniqueness” or “originality” or “sincerity” of the vow that carries its force but precisely what Derrida calls its “iterability” or “citationality,” its repeatability, its utter unoriginality (Culler: 316-17). So it is that we find ourselves at this moment in the middle of a vow that is itself largely about vows. That such a vow may itself be taken as highly “original” perfectly exemplifies Derrida's point about statement and context that provides the lift in George Carlin's joke about airport security signs: If we wrote a vow about vows, you would have to take it seriously, wouldn't you?

So it isn't that you, Allison and Carey, have said particular words, or even that you have performed particular acts such as the customary exchanging of rings to symbolize your commitment to each other.

[Cary and Allison exchange rings.]

Rather, it is that you have agreed to do and say these things under certain binding circumstances—circumstances to which you have, as it were, surrendered yourselves.

And now I will say, “by the power vested in me,” that I now pronounce you husband and wife. Cary, you may now kiss not your girlfriend, or your domestic partner, but your wife with a binding force more powerful than all the kisses that came before.

[Cary and Allison kiss]


This is Till Derrida do us part, originally from August 2002, published Thursday, August 25, 2005. It is part of Arts & Letters, which is part of Readings, which is part of Harpers.org.

link to the original posting

Tuesday, December 13, 2005

CHAPTERS 38:1–42:17 (by IAN FRAZIER, the New Yorker)


Illustrator Note: “Sorry boys, the production work is being shipped to the South Pole.” (Santa Claus, laying-off his worker elves.)

Issue of 2005-12-19
Posted 2005-12-12

by Ian Frazier

Jobless sits, wretched, upon a curbstone. Everything he possessed has been taken from him. His accounts have been closed, house sol for taxes, warranties voided, policies cancelled, back wages garnisheed. His wife has left him for a vintner. His children have run away He has become aff icted with piles, boils, and scours. Creditors give him no peace.

Three of his friends, pitying his sufferings, visit Jobless and try to raise his self-esteem. Their exhortations only cast him farther down. They depart and he is alone. A righteous man, Jobless nevertheless begins to grumble, questioning the purposes of God. From nowhere, with a great manifestation, God appears.


Then the Lord answered Jobless out of the whirlwind of hot-dog wrappers and plastic drink tops with straws still stuck through them, saying, “Who is this that darkens counsel with poorly researched statements? Suck up your insides into yourself like a man, and hear me, and answer what I will ask.

“Where were you when I laid the cornerstones of the Nation? When I made the fields smooth but at a very slight angle, so the rains would run off, and set the boundary markers, and fixed the posts deep in the earth, so they would not fall down? Speak, if you know.

“When I put the land under my special protection, and all the fifty stars sang for joy, did you apprehend the song, or can you say what it was? And when I gave order to the leagues, each in its proper activity and season, and drew up the divisions, and the arrangement of calendars, the days and nights thereof, were you there also?

“Those who love me and praise my works enjoyed mighty victories in my name. The Dallas eleven held hands in a circle and bowed their heads and prayed with one voice to me, and I went before them on the field, and those opposing them fell, and Dallas overcame, and won it all not only once but five times. Tell me how I accomplished that, if you know.

“Have you seen the fastnesses where Overtime and Sudden Death abide? Can you explain, near the end of the year, who exactly is eliminated, and why, or can you say who will be chosen for the bowls? The runner who solicits my blessing leaps beyond his enemies; I cause their feet to stumble as if entangled in a snare, and they are laid low. Victorious, he kneels by the cushioned pole, removes his helmet, and prays earnest thanksgivings to me with a great host looking on. What is your complaining, compared to this?

“Yes, and consider even this example: When my servant David Ortiz, last year or the year before, in an important situation, entreated me in his heart for a hanging curveball, and I heard him, and ordained a hanging curveball to be thrown, and he smote it hip and thigh, and ended up at second, and stood there in the lights pointing straight up to the firmament where I in fact was, David Ortiz praising me before all the assembly and those at home, did you then understand the vastness of my power, or can you unfold for me the art of causing hanging curveballs in important situations which I employed there?

“Can you make a thirty-cubit putt drop at your command? The faithful petitioner squats upon his haunches, he weighs and judges the path, he closes his eyes and silently raises a solemn prayer to me. Are you conversant with the ways of the Bermuda grasses, and do you comprehend how the inclination of their blades to one direction or another affects what rolls upon them? Know you how the little pieces of plant food, invisible in the grasses’ lower depths, have a significant influence for success or ruin? Surely this knowledge, which is mine abundantly from the beginning of the world, is yours as well.

“Does your mind contain the winning numbers for tomorrow’s PickSix lottery? Correctly, in sequence as they will be drawn? Indeed, mine does—and not only for tomorrow’s, because I have ordained all numbers for every drawing for endless ages to come. Those who so beseech me, and keep my covenants, and do no very unclean thing, and buy chances faithfully, but also are above eighteen, I will reward an hundredfold with awareness of the numbers given to them in dreams. Can you do likewise? Speak, you, and answer me.”


Then Jobless, eyes averted, thus addressed the Lord: “I am dumbstruck at your power. How you do it, I in my weakness am unable t understand. You are the Man, the Almighty One. What additional can I say?
And again the Lord spoke, thundering: “Nor have I revealed to you here even a tenth of a tenth of a thousandth part of my dominion. When the rulers, and the captains of great armies, stand before the people, do they not unfailingly invoke my name? And when they ask me to bless the Nation do I not bless it, above and beyond, so that the richest oil anoints it, running down the head even into the beard, in such abundance as to comprise a quarter part of all the oil there is in the world? Does beneficence of this size lie also within your abilities?

“And though you complain against your rulers, and call them hypocrites, vipers, and fools, yet I tell you that they often speak to me in private, and I listen to their requests, and give them counsel, not in so many words, but as it were intangibly. For, if they are fools, why then are they the ones in authority, and not you? Have you ever been to a leadership prayer breakfast on the highest floors, nearer to the heavens and to me? No, truly, this you have never done, not even a single time, and yet you cry to me for aid. Neither do you listen to or watch my messengers, or send them the contributions that they ask for. Are you one of the mighty host whom they can summon even at the last minute to do as I have instructed? Behold, you do not even know what I am talking about, thanks to the virtual blackout these kinds of tidings generally receive.”


The Lord continuing in this vein for a while, Jobless waited patiently upon his curbstone, scratching his boils with a tail-light shard an paying heed. And when finally night had become day and the Lord had finished speaking, Jobless confessed his humility and joblessnes and manifold failings before the Lord, and prostrated himself, and blessed the Lord. And the Lord lifted Jobless up, and restored to him al that he had had before: children, and ex-wives, and house, and breezeway, and yard, and means of transport, and domestic animals, an temporary occupation without benefits restored He

And one night Jobless dreamed of six fat cattle with numerals on their sides, and when he awoke he paid the amount required and entered these numerals in the lottery, and lo! the very same were drawn, and Jobless grew wealthy and well favored until his money was no more.

And it came to pass that Jobless, from not seeing a physician as regularly as recommended, died and went to join his ancestors. And the years of Jobless’s life at that time were sixty-three.


In 1999, an archeological study led by scientists from Northern Illinois University examined several sites traditionally associated with the Jobless story, and could find no evidence that it had ever occurred. The only artifact offered as proof, a leather lottery ticket, was later identified as dating from a different time. Current scholarship regards the tale of Jobless in terms less of history than of myth. Indeed, its exaggeration is part of its appeal; no actual person, then or now, probably has luck that bad. One would be wrong to dismiss the story out of hand, however. After Jobless, never again would the Divinity address mankind so clearly or at such length. Never again, that is, unless you count a snack-cart man I talked to last week in a lobby in midtown. He said to take the Giants and the under, and I did, and made eighty-seven dollars.

link to the original posting